The question that was asked at our table, Team Two. "Let's go against society", and "And we will be setting things right it we stick to this" seemed to be the main trains of thought that rushed around our little group of three. We were losing bad at the game. Like, our face was in the mud while everyone else was still running the course yards ahead kind of bad."You must have the most amount of points to win. This is real life."
The game carried on to round three, and things didn't start to look up. But we were determined to make out statement. Y? We still voted on. We weren't causing the problem, but we weren't becoming the solution either. Our fellow regional Teams (One, Three, and Four) just continued to gain ground on us, trying their best to look out for their groups to win the game, or just blindly going along. It seemed so obvious to us Two's that Y was the answer, but why didn't everyone else get it? Our region could do better than the second region (Five, Six, Seven, & Eight), and I wanted to see them become the example by ours gaining more points than theirs. We'll win as a regional society, even if our Team Two would be the lowest scoring in the group. It's winning so long as we're ahead of them in the points, right?
"Pick your delegates."
Yes! Everyone in our region has agreed to the Y! We're so awesome. Look at us, we got it right. And look at that other region. Our society is doing so much better than theirs. My Team Two is still far behind everyone else in our region, but hey, at least we aren't that other regional society. They need to really be figuring things out now, we're getting ahead of them by a lot.
"Last round for ten times the points."
HECK YAW. We totally just won! Well, our regional society did. Sucks for you, region two! Aha, yeah, we totally got this theology stuff.
"Team Two, you still lost. (And you're pious, yup.)"
Buh- what? I was completely confused. I scanned over the board, trying to figure it out. Y was the innocent vote. Y didn't hurt anyone. Well, except for our Team Two. And I guess it didn't help the other losing teams. But they should have just voted Y from the start, and it would of been a perfect score for all of us!
"This is real life."
But I guess it couldn't have been that way. None of us knew what we were really doing when the damage was done. Fact was, the damage existed. And unless our society was willing to face that, we'd always be low on the point system, and never able to gain ground, until we were draw into trying to compete. Our society was flawed. But hey, we were still ahead of our other regional society. As a whole we were better off... But I suppose that's competition in itself. We fought to look "Right" but we were just doing the same as everyone on a slightly bigger scale. We wanted to see our brother region lose. But we're the ones who lost. Blinded by our own self righteousness we failed to see the bigger picture, the real problem. We failed to see the true need for equality. We let our team take the unneeded fall, instead of grabbing the problem by the roots, and revealing what it was. We wanted equal points, not to be ahead of the lowest loser. Kicking the dog, but acting numb to the foot smacking us in the stomach, saying it was okay. That it'd be okay for our kids to bear. So long as we weren't the loser.
But I am the loser, and so are you.
Good stuff. I'm sure there are more lessons to be drawn from the exercise than we'll even realize during this 8 weeks. A few things stood out to me.
ReplyDeleteIt's true that societies where there is less inequality enjoy a higher average standard of living and better "quality of life" metrics (more on that here http://www.ted.com/talks/richard_wilkinson). Cooperation does have tremendous power to heal the wounds of competition. But anywhere that inequality remains, people will by no means be free from competition, greed and envy (and the gospel is hindered).
It's equally true that in practice we're incapable of complete altruism. Going "all Ys" does engender a sort of piety, but is accompanied by a subtle and insidious self-righteousness. The mainstream American church maintains a victimhood complex and the middle-class claims solidarity with the poor simply by merit of having less than the 1%. All this false piety breeds a sort of complacency toward real injustice and continuing inequality.
It's also true though that the historically privileged ("winners") suffer from a spiritual slavery and need to be called to repentance. The responsibility to call them to repentance (and reparation http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/05/the-case-for-reparations/361631/) is shared among both repentant "winners" as well as historical "losers" (I cringe just typing that term), so there really is no place for the sense that "as long as we all move forward with all Ys it's good enough."
I bumped into three classmates at Starbucks after class (we are so effing privileged, it's ridiculous), and was really encouraged to see what appeared to be passionate reflection on the night's events. This post is just further evidence that the class leadership has captured everyone's attention. Exciting and devastating times ahead - much to be thankful for. :)
The spirit of competition is deeply engrained in my psyche. I did not know this about myself prior to Wednesday night, but once we started the exercise I was motivated to "win all you can."
ReplyDeleteNo matter what we are doing we should always try to follow Jesus. However, I was content to put my morals aside because in my mind it was just a "game." I was on team 2, the winning team with the overall highest score. We took the lead early on, and I was content to stay the winner while round after round the other teams diligently picked Y's despite their inability to ever catch up. I was amazed at how easy taking the win was.
Not only was I motivated to win, but I even tried to persuade my teammates in the final round to pick X and get an extra three points at the expense of the three other teams. Eventhough we were going to win anyway, greed spurred me on to want to win by more.
In life I have tried my best to submit to God's plan on big decisions about where to work, where to live, how to spend my money, and who to be in relationship with. I can see now the importance of that submission because if I was left to my own selfish desires I would let my compulsion to win rule me and trun me into a monster.
I'm sure there are still certain areas of my life that I have not yet fully submitted to Jesus because my selfishness blinds me to them. It is my hope that this class will help the scales fall from my eyes.